HdL presents an update on California’s retail economy based on current 4th Quarter 2023 data. Download the presentation deck to follow along with the recording.

 

 

Related Resource: California Sales Tax Trends & Economic Drivers Report with Beacon Economics

 

Transcript

Overview of Q4 2023 Results

The fourth quarter of 2023 encompasses the holiday shopping season, representing the peak revenue generation cycle of the year. Results were disappointing, as statewide revenue experienced a decline of 2.5%, nearly double the anticipated dip. This persistent trend throughout the 2023 calendar year culminated in subdued performance for the fourth quarter, and apart from the countywide tax pools, overall results trended downward throughout the state. 

Some of the challenges impacting the economy remain high interest rates, consumer spending patterns, and reduced consumer savings. However, there is optimism regarding potential tourism and business travel in the upcoming months. While consumer credit and unemployment rates have seen fluctuations, the overall trend suggests resilience in consumer spending and labor market stability. 

Anticipated action from the Federal Reserve in lowering interest rates is expected to bolster consumer confidence and stimulate increased spending, countering the pattern of 2023 and achieving a soft landing. The forecast indicates a sluggish start to 2024, slightly down over the first quarter, with mild growth beginning in the summer months and continuing through 2024 as interest rates and consumer confidence start to change.

Major Industry Groups: Autos

The Auto and Transportation group were a significant contributing factor to the decline in sales tax receipts, experiencing a decline of just over 6% in the fourth quarter. This was a surprising deviation from the recent trend of 2 to 3% drops, given the notable increase of 10% in new car sales. This discrepancy is partially attributable to inventory management within the auto market, with inventory levels still below pre-pandemic levels. Significant variations between inventory levels are an additional factor, some experiencing high demand and limited availability while others have excess inventory. Softening vehicle prices, particularly for luxury and electric models, further impacted sales tax revenues. Tightening credit conditions and rising finance rates challenged consumers seeking credit for auto purchases, which contributed further to the decline. 

Despite these headwinds, positive indicators such as increasing inventory and pent-up demand suggest a transition to a more balanced market in the second half of 2024. Prices for new vehicles remain 29% higher than pre-pandemic levels, and credit conditions are expected to loosen. Sales tax receipts in this group are forecast to continue downward through Q1 and Q2 of 2024 before seeing modest increases.

Major Industry Groups: Fuel & Service Stations

Declines in this category slowed to a 6.3% reduction from the previous quarter by the end of Q4 2023. Despite fluctuations in gasoline prices leading to volatility in tax receipts, the market is stabilizing with prices ending in line with YOY comparisons. The United States has recently achieved record levels of domestic crude production, surpassing all-time highs in global history. This remarkable growth in production, facilitated by advancements in technology such as shale extraction, positions the United States as a potential force for stabilizing oil prices globally. As a result, the projection is that this will result in relatively flat pricing for fuel and service station revenue in the coming year.

Major Industry Groups: Building & Construction

As expected, the building and construction results fell 1.7%, due to recurring factors impacting revenues for this group. Notably, rising interest rates have negatively impacted the housing market, though the expectation is for moderation in the latter half of 2024. Lumber and concrete prices are rising, with a marked 8.7% increase YOY for concrete, indicating potential for increases in future tax revenues. Weather conditions, particularly significant last year, appear less influential this year, with precipitation levels nearing median levels but still below last year's figures. 

While weak tax revenue results are anticipated for Q1 and Q2, a return to normal growth is projected in the latter half of 2024. Pent-up demand for housing is expected to build momentum for more favorable results in 2025 and beyond.

Major Industry Groups: Food & Drugs

The Food and Drug category saw a notable downturn this quarter, surpassing initial projections with a 6% decrease. Cannabis was a key contributing factor, Q4 marking the 8th consecutive quarterly decline for the sector, primarily attributed to competition from the illicit market. 

Grocery stores, convenience stores, and liquor sales also experienced declines, partially attributed to the inclusion of fueling stations and the associated falling fuel prices impacting these groups. Additionally, shifting consumer preferences towards purchasing alcohol at restaurants rather than liquor or grocery stores has negatively impacted sales receipts. Convenience and liquor store sales saw a 7.8% reduction, accounting for 23% of the group. Challenges related to market saturation in the drugstore segment have resulted in Rite Aid closures across the state and exacerbated by online competition from internet retailers. 

While a slight downturn is anticipated for the first two quarters of 2024, a gradual return to moderate growth near 2% is forecast by the first quarter of 2025. 

Major Industry Groups: General Consumer Goods

General Consumer Goods experienced a notable contraction of 3.3% in the fourth quarter of 2023, surpassing initial projections of a 1.4% decline. The holiday shopping season yielded cautious consumer spending, resulting in a significant downturn in this category compared to the previous year. All four quarters of 2023 saw declines compared to the peak levels of 2022. 

Department stores were the lone bright spot, expanding by 1.5%, attributed to a rebound from store closures in prior periods in addition to increased online fulfillment handled directly by department stores. Discount department stores, comprising 31% of the general consumer goods group, were down 1.4%, significantly contributing to the overall decline. Factors such as fuel pricing, particularly impacting convenience stores, also played a role in these results. 

Tightened budgets and elevated interest rates were reflected in consumers’ reduced spending on high-ticket items and home furnishings, electronics / appliance stores continued their downward trajectory. The shift towards non-taxable services and experiences is a contributing factor to the contraction in retail spending. The forecast for general consumer goods indicates a continued slowdown in spending for the first quarter of 2024, with mild growth anticipated thereafter. 

Major Industry Groups: State and County Pools

Despite expectations of a 2% decline, pools experienced a modest increase of 0.6%, indicating resilience in this sector. Of particular note is the performance of the general consumer goods segment within the pools. This category, primarily driven by e-commerce activities, demonstrated notable growth of 2.5% during the period. This stands in stark contrast to the 3.3% decline observed in the general consumer goods in other sectors, underscoring the shift towards online shopping among consumers.

Key trends observed include the dominance of mobile shopping, which surpassed desktop sales for the first time. Additionally, the resurgence of "Buy now, pay later" options, reminiscent of layaway programs, has gained traction, potentially impacting future sales tax revenues as holiday shopping bills come due. 

The business and industry segment within the pools experienced a marginal decline of 2.2% for the quarter. While business services, business-to-business, and IT-related spending also faced significant declines, this was partially offset by notable increases in energy utilities. While a small subset of the pools, restaurants and hotels have gained some traction, fueled by the emergence of delivery services during the pandemic.

Increased utilization of in-state fulfillment centers has shifted the historic 80% pool allocation, 20% direct allocation to a narrower 60%/40% split.  Despite four consecutive quarters of decline, as more fulfillment centers came online the pools experienced mild expansion in Q4. Modest growth is expected going forward near 1% for the remainder of the fiscal year, 2% beginning in 24-25.

Major Industry Groups: Business & Industry

Despite historic growth, the fourth quarter of 2023 saw a 2.2% decline in this group, deviating from the anticipated 1.4% growth. Fulfillment centers, constituting 31% of the group, flattened during this period, contrary to expectations.

Extracting fulfillment centers from the analysis, the remaining sectors within Business and Industry, encompassing diverse fields such as heavy and light industry, farm equipment, wineries, and biotechnologies, collectively declined by an average of 3.5% in Q4. The most substantial declines were observed in medical and biotech equipment, heavy and light industry, and business-to-business services, attributed pricing challenges, demand fluctuations, and slowed IT sales.

Trends for this group indicate no anticipated growth in fulfillment centers, a cautious outlook for heavy and light industry. While Medical/Biotech and Agriculture face headwinds in terms of high interest rates and limited access to capital for investment, Agriculture looks promising as it leans into Ag Tech and AI. 

Overall, cautious optimism is warranted with expectations of a return to mild growth under 1% in the first half of the calendar year 2024, building toward 2% by the end of the year. Wide variability exists among tax bases, emphasized by the unique composition and dynamics of jurisdiction's economic landscape. While statewide averages provide insights, localized factors significantly influence outcomes within the Business and Industry category.

Major Industry Groups: Restaurants and Hotels

The restaurant and hotel sector experienced a growth rate of just under 1%, slightly lower than the anticipated 3% in the final quarter of 2024. Factors contributing to this include reaching a potential tipping point of high menu prices leading to decreased foot traffic, with January data showing that 79% of operators reported slower foot traffic in their establishments. 

The recent enactment of AB 1228, which established a $20 per hour minimum wage for fast food operators, will likely impact business operations and profitability, although the full extent of its effects remains to be seen. The legislation applies primarily to tiered national brands with over 60 establishments, affecting immediate consumption venues where payment precedes dining. Potential trends resulting from this legislation include increased use of ordering apps and kiosk ordering to mitigate the higher labor costs. Forecasts suggest an increase in menu prices for fast food restaurants starting in the second quarter of 2024, accompanied by continued consumer demand for value meals.

The outlook is optimistic in terms of travel and tourism, as spending in this category reached 3% higher than pre-pandemic levels and is expected to grow 7% in 2024 as international travel rebounds. 

Despite the potential challenges posed by AB 1228, overall sector growth is expected to remain positive, with a gradual increase projected throughout fiscal year 2024-2025. Notably, fast food establishments represent approximately 30% of the entire restaurant and hotel category, with only half of these businesses subject to the new legislation, suggesting a moderated impact on overall revenues.

 

 

Q&A

Q: When are interest rates anticipated to fall?

A: It is likely that any adjustments by the Federal Reserve may occur later in the summer, possibly coinciding with the upcoming election cycle. There is a delicate balance to maintain as waiting too long may not yield the desired effects on the economy.

Q: What is the anticipated impact of recent drug store closures?

A: Like any business, these decisions are driven by what is best for their bottom line. While competition is fierce, closures represent opportunities for new retailers to occupy prime locations.

 

 

Attachments
2023 Q4 HdL Consensus Forecast Webinar Slides.pdf [3.4Mb]
Uploaded Thursday, 04 April 2024 by Jenny Kovach

Get In Touch

Required

Invalid Input

Required

Required

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. Required

Required

To help us direct you to the correct department, please choose one of the following:

Required

I'm interested in...
I'm interested in...

Required

Required